A Record Breaking Q4 for Established Brand
An established holiday food gift brand saw profitable acquisition for the first time in a decade.
Winner
+83% ROAS, $2.4M higher Q4 profits y/y
MeasuredFull-funnel results
An established holiday food gift brand saw profitable acquisition for the first time in a decade.
The Challenge
An established premium food brand with a decade of history, Oprah’s Favorite Things recognition, and years of glowing customer reviews was losing ground in an increasingly crowded gifting market.
Ads were flat and undifferentiated in a category where food content competes for attention against some of the most visually compelling material on social media. Audiences need to feel appetite appeal and excitement to try something new, and confidence to gift it to someone they care about.
The stakes were concentrated: 70%+ of the brand’s annual revenue fell in Q4. Neon was onboarded in September, just weeks before Black Friday/Cyber Monday, with no runway for extended testing cycles. The creative library had to be rebuilt and the media strategy restructured before the revenue window opened.
Three compounding challenges made the timeline harder.
First, the brand had never achieved media profitability in its 10-year history. The measurement and efficiency baseline was low.
Second, previous UGC programs had failed to produce profitable content at scale.
Third, the frozen product format created logistics friction for gift purchasers: unclear shipping windows and no ability to schedule orders made gifting feel uncertain at the exact moment buyers needed confidence.
Each required a distinct solution, delivered simultaneously, in compressed time.
The Strategic Insight
The core diagnosis was a consumer trust deficit compounded by friction. The brand had earned its credibility over a decade with press features, Oprah recognition, and years of customer love. But none of that was visible in the ad creative or the purchase experience. Ads were selling a product; they needed to be selling a proven gift. The distinction matters in Q4, when purchasers are choosing for someone else and the stakes of a wrong choice feel high.
The coreinsight: social proof wasn’t a nice-to-have. Proof was the conversion mechanism. Real customer reviews, prominent media feature callouts, and UGC from credible creators would bridge the gap between product awareness and purchase confidence, particularly for first-time buyers making a gifting decision. Reworking ad creative and landing pages around this trust architecture would compound with any media efficiency gains from campaign restructuring.
The second insight was on friction reduction. A frozen food product sold primarily as a gift has a specific barrier: buyers worry about timing. If a recipient isn’t home, or the order arrives too early, the gift fails. Enabling order scheduling so buyers could choose when their gift arrived removed a decision-blocking objection that was suppressing conversion at the bottom of the funnel, where most media investment was pointing.
The Execution
Campaign restructuring started immediately. The existing media approach had flat budget distribution without demand-based allocation. Spend was running in patterns that ignored the sharp seasonality of a Q4-concentrated revenue model with significant day over day changes.
Neon rebuilt the campaign architecture around a demand-responsive plan: spend now concentrated in highest-intent windows. Upper-funnel awareness landed ahead of BFCM, while lower-funnel conversion campaigns amplified as purchase intent peaked closer to holidays.
Creative strategy operated across two distinct layers. Upper-funnel content educated and enticed with appetite appeal, product stories, and lifestyle context that made the brand feel aspirational and worth trying. Lower-funnel content reduced friction and built confidence with shipping guarantees, real reviews, and messaging that made gifting feel easy rather than risky. Each layer had distinct creative briefs, KPIs, and optimization logic.
The result: 83% ROAS improvement from a historical average of 1.35x to 2.47x, and the brand’s first profitable Q4 in its decade-long history. Q4 profits grew $2.4M year-over-year while net media spend was trimmed. The brand sw efficiency and profitability moving together for the first time.
The UGC program was the creative centerpiece. The brand had attempted UGC with previous providers without success. The content hadn’t converted and never scaled.
Neon rebuilt the program from the brief up: creator selection focused on authentic food enthusiasm rather than follower count, creative direction gave creators structured briefs with clear performance hypotheses, and rapid iteration produced hundreds of ad variations from a core set of 35 unique creator concepts.
The result was the brand’s first ROI-positive UGC push: 35 creators, 100 unique video concepts, and 250+ ad iterations. All delivered in 6 weeks, live before BFCM. UGC ran alongside studio creative from a net-new holiday production organized and directed by Neon Growth, modernizing the seasonal content library for the first time in years.
The combined creative program drove a 25% increase in average CTR and provided enough volume to support extended testing through the full Q4 window without creative fatigue.
Conversion optimization targeted the full purchase funnel, beyond the ad creative. Landing pages were reworked with enriched product context including detailed flavor and ingredient information, high-quality photography, recipe suggestions. Prominent social proof was a core focus: real customer reviews, media feature callouts including the Oprah’s Favorite Things recognition, and trust signals that made first-time buyers feel secure in their purchase decision.
AOV strategy addressed the gifting mechanics directly. Bundling strategies, pre-order options, and multi-address order capabilities increased average order value while making the gifting experience more flexible. Allowing buyers to specify delivery windows directly removed the single largest conversion objection for frozen gift products.
The measurement framework tracked AOV, CVR, and contribution margin rather than ROAS alone, ensuring optimization decisions reflected actual business outcomes.
Client Testimonial
The combination of amazing personalities and well-presented data made our company feel comfortable from the start. The team is a joy to work with.
The Results
The Q4 engagement delivered across every metric that mattered for a seasonal food brand with a compressed revenue window.
ROAS increased 83%, from a historical average of 1.35x to 2.47x. This represented media profitability for the first time in the brand’s 10-year history. Q4 profits grew $2.4M year-over-year with less ad spend, driven by improved media efficiency and higher conversion rates across both the ad creative and the purchase funnel.
The UGC program alone was a milestone. After multiple failed attempts with other providers, Neon launched a program with 35 creators that produced 100 unique video concepts and 250+ ad iterations in 6 weeks, all live before BFCM. Creator content drove engagement metrics the brand had never achieved on paid social. Average CTR increased 25% across the creative program, with UGC content consistently outperforming legacy ads.
Website and UX improvements compounded the media gains. Reworked landing pages with enriched product context and social proof improved CVR; order scheduling removed the top conversion objection for gift purchasers; bundling and multi-address strategies increased AOV. The combination of media efficiency, creative volume, and conversion optimization produced the most profitable Q4 in company history, all with lower media spend than prior years.
Case study Summary
Neon Growth delivered the most profitable Q4 in a beloved holiday food brand’s 10-year history, achieving 83% higher ROAS and $2.4M in incremental Q4 profits year-over-year. Onboarded in October weeks before BFCM, Neon restructured media campaigns, directed a studio shoot, and launched the brand’s first successful UGC program while reworking landing pages and removing purchase friction.
Want results like these? Let's talk about your brand's potential.
Book a call →Key Takeaways
Frequently Asked Questions
Bring your growth target and your biggest roadblocks. We'll show you where the next gains are.
Talk to a Partner →Related Results